Choosing the Right Kitchen Countertop Material for Your Renovation

By W. Hemsath

Countertops can drastically change the look of your kitchen, but when planning a kitchen remodel, appearance is only one consideration. The kitchen countertop material you choose will also affect the cost of your kitchen remodel, as well as the durability of your counters and the maintenance they will require.

To help you make the right choice during your kitchen renovation, here’s an updated look at the top trending countertop materials for 2024, including how much they’ll cost you in money and upkeep, how durable they are, and what other homeowners enjoy most about each one.

To make it simple to compare materials, we’ve scored their maintenance and durability in a range of 0-10: 0 being the lowest on maintenance and lowest in durability. 10 is the highest maintenance requirement and the highest in durability. 

 

1. Quartz

• Cost: $70–$150 per square foot (installed)
• Low Maintenance: (3/10); no sealing required, though sealing is recommended for easier cleaning and improved resistance to staining; clean with mild soap and water.
• High Durability: (7/10); non-porous and resistant to scratching and staining, though things like wine can stain if not sealed; heat resistant but only up to 300° F, so trivets are recommended for all hot pans.
• What Homeowners Like Most: Homeowners love quartz for its uniform appearance and wide range of colors and patterns. Its affordability, durability, and low maintenance make it especially attractive for busy households.

2. Granite

• Cost: $50–$200 per square foot (installed)
• Moderate Maintenance: (6/10); requires sealing once a year; clean with mild soap or stone cleaner.
• High Durability: (9/10); resistant to heat and scratching but may be prone to chipping if heavy objects are dropped.
• What Homeowners Like Most: Granite’s natural beauty and unique patterns are major selling points. Many homeowners appreciate the high-end look and feel, as well as its resilience under heavy use. All-natural beauty that comes from the earth.

3. Marble

• Cost: $75–$250 per square foot (installed)
• High Maintenance: (8/10); requires sealing every 3-6 months to prevent staining and etching; clean gently with a pH-neutral cleaner.

• Moderate Durability: (5/10); prone to scratching, staining, and etching from acids (like lemon juice); heat resistant up to 350° F for short periods of time.
• What Homeowners Like Most: Marble is beloved for its timeless elegance and luxurious veining. Homeowners who want a high-end, sophisticated look often choose marble despite its higher maintenance needs.

4. Butcher Block

• Cost: $40–$100 per square foot (installed)
• Moderate Maintenance: (5/10); requires oiling every 1-3 months to prevent drying, cracking, and water damage; clean with mild soap and water.

• Moderate Durability: (6/10); prone to scratches and dents but can be sanded down; not heat resistant and subject to burn marks if trivets aren’t used.
• What Homeowners Like Most: Homeowners love the warmth and natural look and the added functionality that butcher block adds to a kitchen. It’s also one of the more affordable options, making it attractive for budget-conscious renovations.

 

 

5. Concrete

• Cost: $70–$150 per square foot (installed)
• Moderate Maintenance: (7/10); requires sealing every 1-3 years to prevent stains; clean with a pH-neutral, non-abrasive cleaner.
• Moderate Durability: (7/10); prone to hairline cracks if not properly reinforced; resistant to scratching, staining, and heat if properly sealed; can be sensitive to sudden temperature changes.
• What Homeowners Like Most: Homeowners love concrete for its modern, industrial aesthetic and the ability to customize it with embedded materials or unique shapes.

6. Recycled Materials (e.g., Glass Composite)

• Cost: $50–$125 per square foot (installed)
• Low Maintenance: (4/10);  sealing may be required; clean with mild soap or regular household cleaners.
• High Durability: (7/10); resistant to scratches and stains; generally heat-resistant, but care should be taken with very hot items.
• What Homeowners Like Most: Eco-conscious homeowners appreciate the sustainable nature of recycled countertops. They also love the striking, often colorful appearance that can complement a modern kitchen design.

Budgeting for Your Kitchen Countertop

As you plan your kitchen remodel, remember that the cost of a kitchen remodel can vary significantly based on the countertop material you select. Additionally, choosing a material that aligns with your desired esthetic, maintenance level and durability needs will help ensure long-term satisfaction. Whether you prefer the low-maintenance durability of quartz or the natural beauty of butcher block, there is a perfect countertop for every kitchen style and budget.

For homeowners in Utah, it’s helpful to consult with local experts who understand the climate and can recommend materials that will hold up in dry, high-altitude conditions. Whatever your choice, your kitchen renovation can be a stunning success with the right countertop!